The publication in November 2011 of feed-in tariffs for biomethane injected into gas grids opened a new route for a sector previously confined to power and heat. Appetite was real: some 280 projects submitted for study to GRDF, around thirty to GRTgaz and TIGF, and the arrival of developers from wind and solar.
The French paradox is well known. The country holds Europe’s largest biogas resource thanks to its agricultural sector, yet recovered only 526 ktoe in 2009 against 4.2 Mtoe in Germany and 1.7 Mtoe in the UK, under 10 % of a gross potential estimated at 7 to 16 Mtoe.
A scheme that places the incentive downstream
The chosen mechanism rests on guarantees of origin. The gas supplier captures a biomethane premium and keeps a share of it, 25 % as a rule, 100 % where the gas is used as transport fuel, with the balance offsetting compensation paid through a fund managed by Caisse des Dépôts.
The premium breaks into two values. First a carbon value, equivalent to avoided emissions: at €9/t, the early 2012 price, it was worth €1.7/MWh of gas, and could reach €6/MWh by 2020 on a €30/t basis. Second a marketing premium, tied to brand or civic value, estimated by benchmarking green power offers at around 3.5 % of the supply component, close to €1.6/MWh.
In total the green gas premium came to €3.3/MWh in the short term and close to €7.6/MWh by 2020.
Two market dynamics to anticipate
The first is a transfer of value from downstream to upstream. Given development times of four to seven years, tension could emerge between green gas demand and available supply. To secure volumes, suppliers would then pay producers above the feed-in tariff, which was designed as a floor. Our analysis showed that full internalisation of the premium by developers would improve project IRR by 1 to 2 percentage points.
The second is direct supplier involvement in project development. The 10 % target IRR set by the energy directorate was judged insufficient by several investors given the risks: poorly known real costs on upgrading, injection and connection, interruption risk tied to gas quality requirements, uncertain permitting timelines, and cross-border competition for feedstock. On those terms suppliers could invest themselves to secure volumes and capture the commercial value. That is exactly the configuration seen in Germany, where most injected biomethane producers are integrated players.
A scheme whose durability remained to be proven
Two uncertainties weighed. The first was technical: financial valuation of the guarantee of origin rests on self-declaration, straightforward for a catalogue offer but awkward for a packaged or negotiated offer, or for a supplier selling only green gas.
The second was more structural: within the portfolio of decarbonisation technologies, biomethane injection is not among the most efficient. That reality was likely to push policymakers to trim the scheme to what was strictly necessary, and nothing guaranteed that suppliers would keep retaining a share of the premium. Unless, precisely, the sector was conceived not as an energy policy instrument alone but as an agricultural policy instrument as well.
To go further, download our full analysis below or contact our experts.
The downloadable PDF of this study is available in French only.

