Capacity market: seven trade-offs that will decide what consumers pay

pov 2011 05 marche de capacite sept parametres cles fr

France’s electricity market reform law aimed to address the shortfall in peaking capacity investment, at a time when peak demand was growing faster than annual consumption. The transmission operator was running a consultation on the design of the future capacity mechanism. We quantified seven structuring trade-offs.

1. Missing money or full cost of capital?

The objective is to cover the full fixed costs of a peaking plant. Two routes exist. Let generators earn a margin on the energy market and pay the shortfall through the mechanism, around €47/kW, the approach used at PJM. Or prevent any margin on variable costs and pay all fixed costs directly, around €60/kW, the New England approach known as Peak Energy Rent.

In both cases revenue auditing is essential: double payment for capacity would raise the final consumer’s bill by €2 to 3/MWh.

2. How should demand response be integrated?

Direct competition between demand response and generation, with a reduced requirement on activation hours, would reach around 4 GW at €50/kW by 2015. A dedicated demand response quota would reach the same volume but above €100/kW, in exchange for a higher activation hours requirement.

3. Price floor or free price?

Experience from existing markets shows a real risk of capacity value collapsing, sending an unfavourable signal to investors. A price floor would secure part of the payment independently of the energy market, with a typical impact of €10/MWh on the latter.

4. Zonal or national market?

Those running existing mechanisms regard zoning as essential to their success. Local obligations in critical regions could bring the capacity price down to €5/kW/year in unconstrained regions. Implementation is complex within a national energy market, but the approach deserves consideration over the medium term alongside smart grid development.

5. What value for intermittent capacity?

Adapting the North American model would give wind assets capacity revenue of between €1.5 and €12/kW nominal, potentially up to 15 % of current subsidy levels, which could argue for revising the support system. Solar would be valued only marginally. A combined offer pairing renewables with flexible capacity would address the intermittency problem.

6. How should interconnections be treated?

Statistical treatment would reduce supplier obligations and the final bill by €0.5 to 1/MWh, transferring the value of cross-border capacity to the French market.

7. What about tariff-based curtailment?

At their implicit level of remuneration, legacy tariff-based curtailment capacities might not be competitive against generation. If society wishes to preserve them, a separate framework will be needed within the mechanism.

These seven trade-offs are not independent of each other, and each shifts value between generators, demand response providers and consumers. It is their combination, rather than the principle of the mechanism itself, that will determine its effectiveness.

To go further, download our full analysis below or contact our experts.

The downloadable PDF of this study is available in French only.

Want to receive our articles directly in your mailbox?


    To receive our latest studies and publications on the challenges of environmental transformation.

    Container ship at sunset

    We operate all over the world