Community generation: threat or lever for utilities and developers?

pov 2013 06 modeles communautaires production distribuee fr

Distributed generation long developed through conventional capital-intensive models led by specialists, utilities or developers. An alternative has taken hold: community models, which bring local authorities, neighbours, consumers and citizens into the development of shared generation assets, usually renewable.

Four converging dynamics

  • Retail appetite for local and socially motivated investment, applying short-circuit logic to electricity as a product.
  • Growing involvement of local authorities in energy questions, with local jobs and economic activity in view.
  • The new profitability of self-consumption and the anticipated competitiveness of distributed generation against centralised generation.
  • Social acceptability, which local participation in the capital directly helps to resolve.

A cost of capital well below market standards

This is the central economic driver of these structures. They exploit the multiple roles of cooperative members, simultaneously investors, consumers and taxpayers, and combine several routes to monetising energy: feed-in tariffs, market prices, real self-consumption value or virtual net metering. Tax mechanisms and non-market risk-return preferences add to this.

The result is a cost of capital markedly lower than a conventional developer’s, which changes the economics of marginal projects.

Foreign precedent gives the order of magnitude

In Denmark, Germany and the United States, the community approach is long-established, in places tied to the beginnings of rural electrification, and regained momentum under revised regulatory frameworks.

In Germany, the 2006 law on Energiegenossenschaften simplified the creation of energy cooperatives to the point of making them a central vehicle for renewable development: there were 86 in 2006 and more than 650 by 2013. In the United States, community wind then accounted for close to 2 GW, more than 5 % of installed wind capacity.

In France, a few initiatives modelled on northern European practice were appearing. But the terminology covers sharply different realities depending on the country, the actors involved, their motivations and the financing structure.

A dilemma for utilities

On a first reading these models are a competitive threat to the core centralised generation business. They are also a source of opportunity: easier project development, lower capex requirements, access to cheaper financing, retention of the commercial relationship on the supply side, and an answer to the expectations of concession-granting authorities.

The winning model remained uncertain. The available structures, mixed public-private companies, dedicated investment vehicles, cooperatives, do not share the same financial properties in terms of deconsolidation or dilution, nor the same security where operational control sits outside the utility, nor the same liquidity and exit flexibility.

Two underlying questions remained open, and they have lost none of their relevance. Is there as much profit in a service model operating jointly owned assets as in an ownership model? And do incumbents genuinely hold the competitive advantages that would let them dominate this market?

To go further, download our full analysis below or contact our experts.

The downloadable PDF of this study is available in French only.

Want to receive our articles directly in your mailbox?


    To receive our latest studies and publications on the challenges of environmental transformation.

    Container ship at sunset

    We operate all over the world