Electric vehicles: were utilities underestimating the disruption ahead?

pov 2011 03 arrivee du vehicule electrique et utilities fr

The emergence of electric mobility raised hopes of a reshaped transport value chain, even of disruption in the energy sector. Carmakers, transport operators, electrical equipment makers, telecoms firms and start-ups were all asking whether they could capture the energy-related value: installing and managing charging infrastructure, managing charging, and vehicle-to-grid and vehicle-to-home services.

We interviewed around twenty managers at utilities, distributors and local players in France and Germany to take stock as the market was forming.

A shared bet, limited investment

In both countries utilities had backed electric vehicles, driven by public incentives, the leading role of local authorities and the ambitions of European carmakers. One nuance stood out: in Germany, gas utilities stuck with a natural gas vehicle or mixed strategy, encouraged by a government supporting three technologies simultaneously, electric, fuel cell and gas. France had concentrated on electric mobility since 2009.

Every major utility took part in trials, but the sums committed stayed modest: on the order of a few tens of millions of euros over 5 to 10 years, excluding networks, against the €1 billion of infrastructure investment expected in France.

That caution reflected an acknowledged dependence on public policy. Expectations were explicit: confirm support for the industrial sector, clarify infrastructure financing, seen as a precondition for market take-off, and strengthen the state’s role as programme leader.

A defensive rather than strategic reading

This is the survey’s most interesting finding. For most utilities interviewed, electric vehicles were seen above all as an opportunity to strengthen relationships with local authorities, positioning themselves as quasi project-management support on the roll-out of an EV policy.

Few saw the shift as potential disruption, largely because of the estimated size of the associated energy supply market. That reading seemed to us to underestimate two effects.

Two blind spots

The commercial trigger. Buying an electric vehicle or a fleet is one of the few acts that leads a customer to reconsider their electricity contract, and therefore potentially their supplier. That requires new customer journeys, a subject then barely addressed.

Tariff innovation. The new uses tied to electric mobility offered considerable scope for innovation: energy-only packages, mileage packages, unlimited offers, usage-constrained offers, prepaid arrangements, price per kilometre driven. Electric vehicles could thus become utilities’ first significant experience of billing tied to usage economics, a form eventually extendable to other domestic uses.

That prospect required deep knowledge of customer behaviour that utilities in neither France nor Germany possessed. Failing immediate disruption, electric vehicles could at least serve as a full-scale test.

To go further, download our full analysis below or contact our experts.

The downloadable PDF of this study is available in French only.

Want to receive our articles directly in your mailbox?


    To receive our latest studies and publications on the challenges of environmental transformation.

    Container ship at sunset

    We operate all over the world