A smart gas grid does not offer the same prospects as its electricity equivalent, for one simple reason: gas can be stored. What the growing interconnection of the two networks does open up is arbitrage between gas and power markets, traditionally the preserve of combined cycle plants.
That arbitrage is now moving towards the end customer, driven by new equipment, hybrid heat pumps, micro-CHP units, by direct access to wholesale prices, and by regulatory change, notably capacity payments.
A test case: the micro-cogeneration aggregator
We modelled the business case for an aggregator of 1 to 3 MWe cogeneration units installed alongside an existing gas boiler, in commercial buildings above 10,000 m2: hotels, shopping centres, public buildings.
The question was not theoretical. Several foreign markets had seen significant micro-cogeneration growth. In Germany, alternative supplier LichtBlick set out to deploy 100,000 EcoBlue units, domestic mini-plants built by Volkswagen from one of its engines.
The end of feed-in tariffs changes the equation
At the end of the twelve-year purchase contract, existing installations lose the benefit of the EDF purchase tariff across the five winter tariff months, unless they reinvest around €380/kWe. New units receive no support mechanism at all.
Economics are therefore now set against the market, through unit gross margin and marginal production cost. That marginal cost builds from gas procurement adjusted for electrical efficiency, network charges, transaction costs and O&M, less avoided heat cost, itself a function of the host customer’s load duration curve.
Returns are achievable under two conditions
Our analysis shows attractive returns remain possible in France, provided two elements come together.
- Dynamic production optimisation, meaning gas-power arbitrage run simultaneously across forward markets, spot and the balancing mechanism, rather than baseload operation.
- A capacity payment through the mechanisms provided for in the NOME law.
On that basis, an aggregator can achieve an internal rate of return above 10 % under 2011 market conditions.
Model questions remain open
Several choices remained to be settled in designing the winning model: segment selection, including whether opportunities exist in more diffuse markets; customer acquisition strategy and how it dovetails with boiler service providers; and the contractual structure around asset ownership, including whether the host customer could carry the investment.
Significant growth in gas-fired distributed generation would also not be neutral for infrastructure operators, whose gas and electricity network flows would change appreciably.
Beyond the economic opportunity the stake is strategic. These models sit within a deeper trend, the convergence of supply and services. In time customers will not simply want the cheapest kWh: they will want their energy needs handled end to end, consumption and emissions management included, with a controlled bill against a level of price risk they understand and accept.
To go further, download our full analysis below or contact our experts.
The downloadable PDF of this study is available in French only.

