France’s network access tariff funds transmission and distribution networks to the tune of around €13 billion, and represents more than 90 % of the revenues of the transmission and distribution operators. It accounts for around 30 % of French customers’ bills, with a direct impact on industrial competitiveness and household purchasing power.
As the regulator prepared its fourth iteration, a question deserved asking: beyond the technical improvements under discussion, can this tariff become a lever for developing smart grids?
A price signal that does not reflect costs
The tariff has two functions: remunerating network operators and providing a price signal. The mismatch is sharpest on the second.
For a customer connected to the distribution network, the tariff mainly conveys generation cost signals at national level, whereas the cost structure of distribution is largely independent of them. Generators, meanwhile, receive no signal at all: there is no injection tariff on the distribution network, and it is very low on transmission. All network costs fall on consumers, which strips the tariff of any ability to steer generator behaviour.
An energy component far above actual cost structure
The tariff comprises a fixed component, an energy component in €/kWh and a subscribed capacity component in €/kW/year. Within the withdrawal component, the energy part represents between 65 % and 85 % of cost for an average customer.
Yet losses, the only item genuinely proportional to energy consumed, account for just 20 % of the total. Network costs depend on local peak load and are therefore, to a first approximation, fixed. If the tariff mirrored the cost structure, the energy component would be close to 20 %.
One example makes the gap tangible. A second home in a tourist area, and therefore occupied during peak periods, pays a network bill 80 % lower than a primary residence. The impact on network costs is nonetheless broadly the same, the difference amounting only to reduced losses.
The construction has a historical explanation: meters offer only one to six registers, making precise estimation of peak contribution impossible, and distributed consumers are represented by standard load profiles. European benchmarking confirms that an energy-weighted structure is not exceptional, and that France sits in the middle of the range.
Two cases where the blurred signal is costly
Solar grid parity. Under self-consumption the network acts as back-up and the costs paid fall to the fixed component, 25 % of the tariff. Yet the network’s costs are unlikely to fall fourfold as a result. A tariff built on marginal cost would significantly shift the grid parity target.
Smart EV charging. Scheduling charging overnight brings marginal network cost to zero. Marginal pricing would be a powerful incentive to manage load. Spain understood this, introducing a super-off-peak tariff for electric vehicles as early as 2011, with network charges 50 % below standard off-peak rates.
Five possible changes
- Raise the capacity component, to better reflect the fixed cost structure of the network.
- Introduce local curtailment signals in the energy component, and involve the distributor in peak-day signal decisions.
- Create an injection tariff on the distribution network, positive or negative.
- Establish a mechanism for locating network savings from a distributed generation programme.
- Reduce withdrawal charges for storage systems.
These changes face real constraints: tariff equalisation across the country, metering limitations, and consistency with regulated tariffs of which network charges represent 45 % for a residential customer, with legislation requiring convergence through cost stacking.
Even so, reversing the reasoning by placing efficient cost signals at the base of the tariff would mechanically strengthen the economic case for smart metering. For smart grid manufacturers, renewable operators and network operators, this debate is a valuable signal, including for technologies whose deployment runs beyond the tariff horizon, such as storage and microgrids.
To go further, download our full analysis below or contact our experts.
The downloadable PDF of this study is available in French only.

