French energy policy aims among other things to combat the greenhouse effect. Our study assesses the economic efficiency of support schemes against that specific criterion, comparing abatement cost, meaning public subsidy per tonne of CO2 avoided, across some thirty technologies: renewable power, gas and heat, demand response, energy efficiency and green transport.
One methodological point matters. Feed-in tariffs are not directly intended to cut emissions but to bring emerging technologies to competitiveness. Even so, in the short term it is externalities that constitute the concrete benefit society obtains. And externalities other than CO2, trade balance, jobs, supply diversification, are second order against the carbon value of renewables, between €30 and €70/MWh depending on the emission factor of the marginal asset displaced.
A tenfold spread across power technologies
The first finding is dispersion. Abatement costs across renewable power technologies vary by a factor of ten.
Only onshore wind performs reasonably, at around €40 to 50/tCO2, against reference values: the Quinet report proposed €32/t in 2010 rising to €100/t by 2030, and the Stern report’s social cost of carbon sits at €70/t.
For the other power technologies, the burden placed on consumers through the renewables levy runs between €200 and €400 per tonne avoided. In total, 75 % of the renewable portion of the levy funds technologies that perform poorly on the CO2 criterion.
Performance that will mechanically deteriorate
The study’s most counter-intuitive finding concerns the trajectory. The carbon performance of renewable power deteriorates as nuclear’s share of the mix falls.
The logic is arithmetic. A nuclear MWh emits no CO2. Each nuclear MWh removed is replaced by a fraction of renewable MWh, also carbon-free, and a fraction of fossil MWh backing up the intermittent output. In a nuclear phase-out scenario combined with heavy renewable deployment, emissions in 2025 could rise by 50 % against 2011, from 30 to 45 million tonnes a year.
A second effect: the carbon content of the marginal MWh displaced also falls as gas progressively replaces coal, which emits twice as much. Renewable output therefore decarbonises less, and the tonne avoided costs on average 50 % more in subsidy than today. The same holds in Germany, where three quarters of renewable subsidies fund technologies above the social cost of carbon.
The gas paradox
The analysis produces an unexpected result. If gas plants sought a subsidy to stay in operation on emissions grounds alone, their abatement cost would rank among the best in the study.
A coal kWh contains around 2.5 times more CO2 than a gas kWh. Replacing gas with coal is therefore environmentally damaging. A subsidy equal to the missing money of gas assets, around €60/kW in 2011, would deliver a more reasonable abatement cost than most renewable power technologies.
Energy efficiency remains the best performer
Beyond generation, energy efficiency tops the ranking. Some measures are inherently profitable, producing a negative abatement cost. For the rest, the cost stays low against generation technologies.
That raises a prioritisation question. Since the levy exists to bring technologies to competitiveness, and given the criticism directed at energy savings certificates, it could be worth creating a levy-type mechanism to subsidise directly those efficiency measures that are not profitable at current energy prices.
To go further, download our full analysis below or contact our experts.
The downloadable PDF of this study is available in French only.

