Gas storage: why shippers stopped filling French sites

pov 2012 07 valeur du stockage de gaz naturel fr

The French gas system only guarantees security of supply against a one-in-fifty-year weather event if storage sites are full at the start of winter. They no longer were, because the gap between the commercial price of storage and the value shippers place on it had become too wide. Our interviews with fifteen market participants, nine suppliers, four traders and two large consumers, explain why.

Three ways of valuing the same asset

  • The own-use supplier. Modest French footprint, local portfolio management, limited access to European flexibility. Storage covers the volume risk of a portfolio of industrial customers on tolerance-band contracts. Its cost is set against commercial margin: if the spread is €4 and storage costs €5.40, €1.40 has to be justified out of margin.
  • The mature supplier. Scale and experience giving direct access to the whole European market, with strict separation between commercial and trading desks. Storage competes head-on with northern hubs, foreign storage, LNG, swing production and virtual storage. Disengagement is purely a competitiveness question: subscriptions are limited to regulatory obligations.
  • The pure trader. No physical need for storage. The market is always right, and if the price of storage sits outside the market price, they do not buy. These players highlight the cultural gap with a French commercialisation process built on administered prices, where in their view only auctions would reveal true value.

Competition has become close to perfect at the northern hub

Storage was unavoidable while markets were illiquid: import capacity could not meet winter peak, and an unstocked shipper faced liquidity default risk.

The build-out of interconnections with northern Europe and of LNG terminals removed that constraint. French storage now competes directly with TTF, NBP and Zeebrugge, whose prices and volatilities are strongly correlated with the French hub. A shipper finding cheaper capacity in the Netherlands buys there, redirecting flows if needed.

A classic infrastructure cycle compounds this, amplified by the economic downturn: capacity shortage, high prices, new investment, overcapacity, low prices, capacity withdrawal.

Option value is weaker than expected

All mature players say they factor in option value. Several nonetheless stress it is weak in practice, not for lack of volatility but because of the constraints on its use: mandatory stock level on 1 November, tolerance bands, reduction factors, interruptible network access. Genuinely monetisable short-term flexibility is smaller than assumed.

Intrinsic value must also be net of costs that are often understated: around €0.45/MWh for injection and withdrawal, and above all close to €0.8/MWh of capital cost on gas held for six months.

Conversely, storage carries a real premium over a simple spread position: intra-day availability when markets are thin, cover for non-standard volumes, and aversion to execution risk in a market of uncertain depth.

Strategic value is ignored, and that is the real issue

Security of supply is absent from the economic reasoning behind purchase decisions, either through a poor understanding of a supplier’s obligations or through ambiguity in the regulatory framework itself.

The gap between price and market value then reads as missing money, comparable to that seen on peaking power capacity between spot prices and replacement cost. The parallel points to the same answer: evolve gas market design so that a capacity mechanism pays for the value the energy market does not reveal, and covers the full cost of storage.

To go further, download our full analysis below or contact our experts.

The downloadable PDF of this study is available in French only.

Want to receive our articles directly in your mailbox?


    To receive our latest studies and publications on the challenges of environmental transformation.

    Container ship at sunset

    We operate all over the world