Renewable aggregation: a €3 billion market was taking shape in France

pov 2014 06 agregation production renouvelable fr

Renewable financing mechanisms were changing in nature across Europe. New state aid guidelines for energy had been published by the Commission in April 2014, and Germany was finalising its EEG 2.0 reform. The direction was clear: direct market access, topped up by a premium generally paid ex post.

That shift mechanically creates a role, the aggregator, linking hundreds of distributed generation plants to the wholesale market.

A French market of up to 30 GW

We put the potential French market for renewable generation aggregation at up to 30 GW, around €3 billion of revenue by 2020. Three drivers pointed there.

  • Feed-in tariff contracts reaching maturity, running 15 or 20 years depending on the technology.
  • Growth of the renewable fleet, alongside financing rules evolving in line with European guidance.
  • A possible incentive to switch to market-based valuation for output still under tariff, as had been done in Germany.

Cogeneration and demand response, which also require an aggregator, were excluded from this sizing as their characteristics are too specific.

Germany as a full-scale demonstration

The German case left little doubt about the effect of a legislative change. After the 2012 EEG law, installations under feed-in tariffs could access the market and be paid through an ex post premium. A management premium made that access more attractive. The result: close to 40 GW aggregated, and the rapid emergence of an ecosystem connecting producers to the market.

The German market then counted around twenty players of varying size. Statkraft, the Norwegian utility, managed on its own almost as much wind capacity as the feed-in tariff mechanism.

Economies of scale shape the market structure

An aggregator’s costs concentrate in two places: imbalance costs, the gap between actual and forecast output, and overheads. Both are subject to marked economies of scale, which imposes a critical size. We expected consolidation in the German market over the short to medium term.

For players positioning themselves in a French market likely to follow a similar path, two imperatives stood out: reaching a portfolio above critical size quickly, and minimising imbalance costs. In a market likely to attract many entrants, those two variables build the competitive advantage.

To go further, download our full analysis below or contact our experts.

The downloadable PDF of this study is available in French only.

Want to receive our articles directly in your mailbox?


    To receive our latest studies and publications on the challenges of environmental transformation.

    Container ship at sunset

    We operate all over the world